- 8 min read
Google’s AI Answers Have Cut Website Clicks Nearly in Half. What Australian Businesses Should Do Before the Traffic Goes

Contents
- 8 min read
Google now answers a growing share of searches itself, in a box that sits above the blue links, and when that box appears far fewer people click through to a website. A contributor piece in Startup Daily on 29 October made the case that the way to survive this shift is not to out-rank Google but to become the source the AI quotes. The evidence for why that matters is already on the record: when an AI summary shows up, clicks to websites nearly halve.
If your organic traffic has started to slide and you cannot see why, this is a large part of the reason. Digital One Agency builds SEO and AI-search visibility for Australian businesses in exactly this position, and the quickest way to find out where you stand is a free AI readiness audit. First, though, it helps to understand what is actually happening on the results page.
What an AI Overview does to your click
An AI Overview is the summary Google generates at the top of the results for many queries, stitched together from pages it has crawled. The reader gets an answer without leaving Google. For a straightforward question, that is often the end of the search. The links are still there underneath, but a box that already answers the question gives most people no reason to scroll past it.
This is the part business owners underrate. You can hold the number one organic position and still lose the visit, because the AI answer now stands between your listing and the reader. Ranking well is necessary. On its own it is no longer sufficient.
Not every search is affected equally, which is the first thing to work out about your own exposure. Pew found the summaries were far more common on longer, question-shaped queries: 60 per cent of searches that began with a question word produced one, and the rate climbed to 53 per cent for searches of ten words or more. Short, brand or clearly transactional searches were much less likely to trigger a summary. So if your enquiries come mostly from people typing questions about how to solve a problem, you are squarely in the firing line. If they come from people already searching your name or ready to buy, you have more breathing room.
The numbers, and what they mean for your business
The clearest measurement comes from the Pew Research Center, which in July 2025 tracked the real browsing of 900 US adults across nearly 69,000 Google searches in March that year. On visits where an AI summary appeared, people clicked a traditional search result just 8 per cent of the time. On visits without one, they clicked 15 per cent of the time, nearly twice as often. Clicks on a link inside the summary itself were rarer still, at 1 per cent of visits.
Two more figures matter. Readers who saw a summary were more likely to stop searching altogether: sessions ended on 26 per cent of pages with an AI summary, against 16 per cent without. And this was not a fringe experience even in early 2025. Pew found that 58 per cent of people ran at least one search that month which produced an AI summary, with roughly one in five individual searches showing one.
Run that arithmetic against your own site. If a fifth of the searches that used to find you now surface an AI answer first, and the click-through on those searches roughly halves, you have quietly lost close to a tenth of your search-driven visits before you touch a single page. For a business that gets most of its enquiries from Google, that is not a rounding error. It is a line through the budget.
Google disputes the reading, arguing the clicks that do get through are higher quality, from people with stronger intent. It has not published data to back that up. Search Engine Journal, reviewing the same study, was blunter, headlining its write-up with the claim that AI Overviews are eroding the web ecosystem. The Pew data is US-only and from early 2025, so treat the exact percentages as a signal rather than a forecast for your market. The direction is not in doubt.
Want this built or fixed for your business?
Digital One Agency builds AI systems, apps, platforms and AI-search visibility for Australian businesses. Start with a free AI audit or book a meeting and we will tell you what it would take.
You cannot switch it off, so stop waiting for it to pass
Plenty of business owners assume this is a setting Google will eventually let them opt out of, or that readers will toggle away. Neither is true. Google treats AI Overviews as a core search feature, in the same bracket as the knowledge panels that show business hours and phone numbers, and says plainly they cannot be turned off. A reader can tap the Web filter to see only links on a given search, but almost nobody does, and you cannot make them.
That changes the right response. This is not a storm to wait out. It is the shape of search now, and the businesses that adjust early will be the ones cited while their competitors are still refreshing their rankings report and wondering where the visitors went.
What actually gets you cited
Being quoted inside an AI answer is a different job from ranking, though the two overlap. The assistants pull from sources they already trust, and they reward being referenced across many credible sites rather than winning a single keyword. The Startup Daily piece set out a short, sensible playbook, and it matches what we see in client work:
- Find out what the assistants already say. Ask ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity the questions your buyers actually type, and note which sources they lean on. That tells you who you are up against and where the gaps are.
- Earn references from places the models respect: industry associations, journalists, respected publishers in your field. A spread of trusted sites pointing at you counts for more than one strong backlink.
- Publish things worth citing. Original figures, a clear answer to a question nobody else has answered well, a genuine expert view. Thin, me-too content gets skipped by both Google and the assistants.
- Structure pages so a machine can lift the answer cleanly: a direct response near the top, plain headings, facts stated once and clearly.
One caution on the evidence. The Startup Daily analysis was run by the author’s own firm, covered 360 AI-search responses in Australia, and shows correlation, not proof of cause. The advice is still sound, because it is the same work that builds durable authority regardless of which engine is reading. It just will not deliver overnight.
Measure it, then spread the risk
Before you change anything, get a baseline. Most businesses cannot say how many of their impressions now carry an AI answer or what that is costing them, because they are still watching rank and raw traffic rather than the click-through on the queries that bring buyers. Google Search Console shows impressions and clicks per query; the gap between them, widening on your informational queries, is the fingerprint of this shift.
Then reduce how much rides on Google alone. Email lists you own, a sharper presence on the platforms your customers use, referral and partner channels, and visibility across several AI assistants all cushion the blow when one source pulls back. The goal is not to abandon search. It is to stop being a tenant on a single platform that keeps rewriting the lease.
What we do about this
Digital One Agency starts with the measurement most businesses skip: which of your queries now trigger an AI answer, what that is doing to your clicks, and which sources the assistants cite instead of you. From there we do the work that gets you referenced, sharpen the pages that should be answering buyer questions, fix the sites that rank but do not convert, and build the owned channels that reduce your exposure to any single platform. If you want a straight read on where you stand, our AI readiness audit is the entry point, and our AI consulting and SEO teams take it from there.
The next step is simple. Book a meeting with Digital One Agency and we will look at your Search Console data with you, tell you how much of your traffic is already exposed to AI answers, and set out what it would take to get your business cited rather than skipped. You will leave the call knowing the size of the problem and the first three things to fix, whether or not you work with us.
Frequently asked questions
What is a Google AI Overview?
It is the AI-generated summary Google places at the top of many search results, built from pages it has crawled. It answers the query directly on the results page, which means many readers get what they need without clicking through to any website.
Can I stop Google showing an AI Overview for my business searches?
No. Google treats AI Overviews as a core search feature and says they cannot be turned off. A reader can apply the Web filter to see only links on a given search, but you cannot force that, and very few people do it.
How much traffic do AI Overviews actually cost?
Pew Research found that when an AI summary appears, people click a traditional result in 8 per cent of visits, against 15 per cent without one, so roughly half as often. The figures are US data from early 2025, so treat them as a strong signal rather than a precise prediction for your site.
How do I get my business cited inside AI answers?
Earn references from sites the assistants trust, publish content worth quoting, and structure your pages so a machine can lift a clean answer. Test the questions your buyers ask across ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Perplexity to see who is being cited now and where your gaps are.
Should I give up on SEO because of AI search?
No. Pages still need to rank and be indexed before an AI engine will cite them, so strong SEO is the foundation, not the opposite. The change is that ranking is no longer enough on its own; you also have to be the source the AI quotes.
Need Custom AI & RAG Pipelines in Australia or the UK?
Digital One Agency is a senior, founder-led engineering team based in Australia (Gold Coast HQ) with active UK clients in London, Manchester and Edinburgh. We build production RAG pipelines and bespoke AI systems — fine-tuning, vector search, evaluation harnesses included.
- Free 30-minute discovery call with a senior engineer
- Fixed-scope quote with milestone billing — no hourly rates
- AU & UK references on request
- Bespoke code you own — not a SaaS reseller, not a ChatGPT wrapper
Book your free discovery call → Or send us your project details
Share
- Get in touch
Kickstart a project today!
Fill out the form, and a member of our team will reach out to discuss your project and answer any questions you might have.